Heat Pumps vs. Solar Panels: Which is Best?

Green energy solutions, like heat pumps and solar panels, are becoming increasingly popular in UK homes. One of the primary reasons for this surge is their crucial role in the UK government's strategy to achieve net zero carbon emissions by 2050.

But when it comes to choosing between a heat pump and solar panels, which is the better choice for your home?

At Make My House Green, we are the experts, and so we have broken down the key information you need to know about both heat pumps and solar panels. These key considerations will ensure you make an informed decision. But if you’re looking for a quick answer, then solar panels are a smart choice for those considering heat pumps in the future. Keep reading to learn why. 

What is a Heat Pump?

Before we dive any further into our comparison, we need to first get a clear understanding of what a heat pump is. 

Heat pumps represent the future of home heating, and they work by gathering small amounts of heat energy from the air or ground and concentrating it to warm up your home. The magic of this process means they are effective regardless of the weather, even in temperatures as low as -15°C.

Heat pumps, like solar panels, contribute to making a home more green by utilising renewable energy sources to reduce carbon emissions. Both systems operate with zero emissions during their use, heat pumps when powered by solar efficiently convert ambient heat into usable energy, and solar panels by harnessing sunlight to generate electricity. Together, they minimise reliance on fossil fuels, lower energy bills, and support a sustainable and eco-friendly home environment. 

But which should you choose first for your home?

5 Solar Panels & Heat Pump Comparisons 

Here are the top five comparisons you need to consider between heat pumps and solar panels, that will help you to make a decision on which to invest in for your home. 

1. Emissions 

When it comes to reducing emissions, both heat pumps and solar panels excel in creating a greener home environment.

Heat pumps are a highly eco-friendly option as they produce no direct carbon dioxide, particulates, or nitrogen dioxide emissions. By extracting heat from the air or ground, they significantly reduce your home's carbon footprint. This process not only benefits the environment but also improves air quality, making heat pumps a clean and sustainable choice for home heating.

Solar panels also contribute significantly to emission reductions by generating electricity from a renewable source—sunlight. During operation, solar panels produce zero emissions, helping to decrease the overall environmental impact of your home. By using solar energy to power your lights and appliances, you reduce dependence on fossil fuels and contribute to a cleaner, greener planet.

Both heat pumps and solar panels offer substantial benefits in reducing emissions, supporting a more sustainable lifestyle and helping to achieve long-term environmental goals.

2. Efficiency

When evaluating efficiency, both heat pumps and solar panels offer substantial benefits, but they operate in fundamentally different ways.

Heat pumps are renowned for their impressive efficiency. By extracting heat from the air or ground, they generate significantly more heat than the electricity they consume. This remarkable efficiency is due to the heat pump's ability to transfer ambient heat rather than generating it directly. In optimal conditions, ground source heat pumps can achieve efficiency levels of up to 400%, meaning they produce four units of heat for every unit of electricity used. This makes them three times as efficient as traditional gas boilers, which translates to lower energy consumption and reduced heating costs.

Solar panels have also seen significant advancements in efficiency over recent years. Modern solar panels typically convert around 20% of sunlight into usable electricity, with high-efficiency models reaching up to 23%. This means that a well-designed solar panel system can provide a substantial portion of your home's electricity needs, especially during peak sunlight hours. While solar panel efficiency is generally lower than that of heat pumps in terms of energy conversion, the ability to harness free, renewable sunlight makes them an incredibly cost-effective and environmentally friendly option for generating electricity.

3. Costs

Understanding the costs associated with heat pumps and solar panels is crucial for making an informed decision. Both options have distinct financial implications, from initial investment to long-term savings.

The upfront cost of installing a heat pump ranges from £7,000 to £13,000. While this may seem steep, there are government incentives to help offset these expenses. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme, for instance, offers grants of £7,500 to assist with installation costs until April 2025. However, it's important to consider additional potential costs. Depending on your home, you might need new radiators or underfloor heating and improved insulation, which can add to the overall expense. 

The cost of installing solar panels varies depending on the size and type of your home, but on average, it costs around £6,000 to install a solar panel system in a three-bedroom house. If you wish to store excess energy generated during the day for use at night, you will need a battery, which for a home of this size costs around a further £2,000. Although the combined cost of panels and a battery can be significant, there are ways to recoup some of these expenses quickly. Solar panels can generate more electricity than your household needs during peak sunlight hours, allowing you to sell excess electricity back to the grid. This can offset the initial investment and lead to long-term savings on energy bills. For a more detailed understanding of the cost and savings of solar panels, use our handy cost calculator. 

4. Durability 

Durability is a key factor to consider when choosing between heat pumps and solar panels. Both options are designed for long-term use, but they differ in terms of lifespan and maintenance requirements.

Heat pumps are known for their longevity and durability. On average, a well-maintained heat pump can last around 20 years. These systems require minimal maintenance, mainly involving regular checks and servicing to ensure optimal performance. The initial high cost of installation is balanced by the long lifespan, meaning you won’t need to replace the system frequently. Additionally, because heat pumps have fewer moving parts compared to traditional heating systems, they are less prone to wear and tear, contributing to their durability.

Solar panels typically have an even longer lifespan, ranging from 25 to 30 years. After this period, while they may continue to produce electricity, their efficiency can decrease. However, many solar panel systems come with warranties that guarantee performance for 20 to 25 years, ensuring reliability and peace of mind for homeowners. Solar panels also require minimal maintenance, usually limited to occasional cleaning and inspections to ensure they remain free of debris and are functioning correctly. The durability of solar panels means that once installed, they provide a long-term, low-maintenance solution for generating clean energy.

5. Installation 

The installation process is a crucial aspect to consider when choosing between heat pumps and solar panels. Each system has specific requirements and complexities that can impact your decision.

Installing a heat pump is a complex process that requires professional expertise. It involves several steps, including evaluating your home’s insulation, determining the best location for the unit, and possibly making significant modifications to your heating system. This might include installing new radiators, underfloor heating, or enhancing your home's insulation. Due to the complexity and the need for precise installation, it’s essential to hire a qualified and experienced installer. While this can be more time-consuming and potentially disruptive, a properly installed heat pump ensures optimal performance and efficiency.

The installation of solar panels is generally less complicated and less intrusive than that of heat pumps. A typical solar panel installation involves an initial assessment of your roof’s suitability, followed by the mounting of panels and connection to your home’s electrical system. The process usually takes a couple of days and causes minimal disruption to your daily life. The relative simplicity of installing solar panels compared to heat pumps makes them a more convenient option for many homeowners.

Which is Better for Your Home: A Heat Pump or Solar Panels?

Ultimately, the choice between a heat pump and solar panels depends on what you value most, whether it’s efficient heating, lower electricity bills, ease of installation, or long-term sustainability. For many homeowners, a combination of both technologies may offer the best of both worlds, maximising energy efficiency and minimising environmental impact.

Heat pumps can add to your energy bills, whereas when used with solar power, this impact is diminished and the payback of solar gets even better!

Solar panels are ideal if you want to generate your own electricity and reduce reliance on the grid. They harness renewable energy from the sun to provide a substantial portion of your home’s electricity needs, potentially lowering your energy bills significantly. The initial cost of solar panels is generally lower than that of heat pumps, and the installation process is simpler and less disruptive. Solar panels also have a long lifespan, typically lasting 25 to 30 years with minimal maintenance. Additionally, they offer the benefit of selling excess electricity back to the grid, providing an extra source of income and further offsetting costs.

‍

Ready to Embrace Solar Energy? 

Choosing between a heat pump and solar panels is a significant decision that impacts both your home’s energy efficiency and your long-term savings. While both options offer remarkable benefits, solar panels stand out for their ability to generate clean, renewable energy and provide substantial cost savings over time. They’re also smart to have in place before you consider adding a heat pump to your home.

If you’re ready to take the next step towards a greener home, we’re here to help. Discover how solar panels can transform your energy consumption and potentially lower your electricity bills. Use our solar panel calculator to find the perfect solution for your home. 

For personalised advice and more information, don’t hesitate to get in touch with our team. At 'Make My House Green,' we specialise in providing tailored solar solutions to meet your specific needs. Learn more about solar panels today to start your journey towards a more sustainable and cost-effective energy future.